It's about that time, and I'd thought a suggestion topic to get this started should be made.

Basically, say what kind of categories and other ideas you have for this thing which we might and should try and do.

My ideas:
-Including non-Nintendo games or having "Best Non-Nintendo Game" category.
-Starting it sometime after Christmas so people have a chance of playing more games (as most people are getting games for Christmas, Hanuka, or whatever).
-Most annoying character (Navi - OoT3D, Bianca - Pokemon B/W)
-Most anticipated title (Kid Icarus: Uprising, Pikmin 3)
-Disappointing game (Legend of Zelda: 4 Swords Anniversary, Plants vs Zombies (DS))

Just some from the top of my head.

Heres some Ideas

-Best PC game
-Best PS3 game
-Best 360 game
-Best 3rd party Wii Title
-Best 3DS launch title
-best Multi-platform game
-Best Meme-starting game

yeah

Flat-out Worst game
Best momemnt in a game
Best Hero in a game
Best Villain in a game
Best Storyline
Best Graphics
Best "Lulz" moment in a game

-Most wanted wii u game (?)
-Best Joe joke
-Best Video game Commercial
-Best Non-Human, non sparky, Mario character
-Best Touhou game (lol)

Best "Gainax moment" in a game
Best "You mad" moment in a game
Best death animation/sound in a game

How about Best Soundtrack?

Best Classic Game?
Biggest wtf game?

most classic
most difficult
most innovative
most replayable
most "bang for your buck"

How about, instead of posting categories only, you actually name some games fitting in that category?

This is a topic to get some good categories and other ideas, but everyone is only posting categories.

Voting is later.
~Medic

I know, but in order to approve a category, you need games to form it...

Most Critically Underated (Skyward Sword, Various 3DS Games...)
Most Critically Overated (MW3, Various PC Games)

Alright then, mama

"
-Best PC game (Cave Story +, Minecraft, Portal 2, Touhou 13...)
-Best PS3 game (Infamous 2, etc.)
-Best 360 game (honestly Im lost here
-Best 3rd party Wii Title (Rayman origins and... er...)
-Best 3DS launch title (all the 3ds launch games, Rayman 3d and such)
-best Multi-platform game (Catherine, Skyrim, etc)
-Best Meme-starting game (Portal 2, Touhou 13, Minecraft, etc.)

Don't forget for best meme creating game Skyrim


That "Arrow to the knee" meme is REALLY big now. It would win XD

i was gonna make some categories, but then i took an arrow to the knee
inb4 RAEG

The title has "and Shizz" in it, so this isnt a category, but we should just have 4 games for each category

No ideas, but here are the awards.

Best Wii Game: The Legend of Zelda Skyward Sword
Best Action-Adventure Game: The Legend of Zelda Skyward Sword
Best Graphics: The Legend of Zelda Skyward Sword
Best 3D Graphics: The Legend of Zelda Skyward Sword
Best Gameplay: The Legend of Zelda Skyward Sword
Most Innovative Game: The Legend of Zelda Skyward Sword
Hardest Game: The Legend of Zelda Skyward Sword
Worst Online: Call of Duty Modern Warfare 3
Worse Game Of The Year: Call of Duty Modern Warfare 3
Best Game Of The Year: The Legend of Zelda Skyward Sword

Yea, I should agree with Skoch. Give me some examples of games in the category you have an idea for, or else I won't count it. I'll do it in my first post.

Also, remember not ALL ideas will be used. Don't be upset in the end, even if you followed the rules.

And don't make it stupid troll shizz.

Best Soundtrack (Mother,Touhou)
Biggest WTF game (MW3)

Pikmintendo wrote:Alright then, mama

"
-Best PC game (Cave Story +, Minecraft, Portal 2, Touhou 13...)
-Best PS3 game (Infamous 2, etc.)
-Best 360 game (honestly Im lost here
-Best 3rd party Wii Title (Rayman origins and... er...)
-Best 3DS launch title (all the 3ds launch games, Rayman 3d and such)
-best Multi-platform game (Catherine, Skyrim, etc)
-Best Meme-starting game (Portal 2, Touhou 13, Minecraft, etc.)

What was the meme started by Ten Desires?

Smash wrote:Best Soundtrack (Mother,Touhou)
Biggest WTF game (MW3)

Pikmintendo wrote:Alright then, mama

"
-Best PC game (Cave Story +, Minecraft, Portal 2, Touhou 13...)
-Best PS3 game (Infamous 2, etc.)
-Best 360 game (honestly Im lost here
-Best 3rd party Wii Title (Rayman origins and... er...)
-Best 3DS launch title (all the 3ds launch games, Rayman 3d and such)
-best Multi-platform game (Catherine, Skyrim, etc)
-Best Meme-starting game (Portal 2, Touhou 13, Minecraft, etc.)

What was the meme started by Ten Desires?

Technically, Ten Desires didnt start a meme (yet) but Touhou is a meme in itself

Smash wrote:Best Soundtrack (Mother,Touhou)

This is 2011 GotY. Mother is not allowed.

@Linko: Tthis is NOT ACTUAL voting/nominations. I just want games to support your idea, they won't exactly count towards anything other than proof.

ok heres mine with more categories and examples

most classic(skyward sword,rayman,sonic generations, kirby)
most difficult(i havent actually played a difficult game this year...)
most innovative(minecraft...some others)
most replayable(mario kart 7,skyrim)
Best soundtrack(mario kart 7,skyward sword,skyrim)
best shooter(BF3,uncharted 3 is also a shooter kind of,killzone, gears of war,)
Best Side Scroller(Kirby,rayman)
Best Platformer(Rayman, SM3DL,Kirby)
Best RPG(Skyrim,xenoblade)
Best Action(Skyward sword,uncharted 3, batman,OOT3D)
Best Racing(mario kart 7,Forza motorsport)
Best Sport game(fifa,nba, the usual annual stuffs really)
Best Fighting Game(SSIV,king of fighters, MvC3,mortal kombat)
Best Multiplayer(mario kart 7,MvC3,BF3,Kirby,rayman)

Platofrm Awards(exclusive only)
Best 3DS Game(SML3d,Mario kart 7,OOT3D,SSIV)
Best Xbox360 game(gears of war 3, halo CE anniversary)
Best PC game(Minecraft...some other stuffs)
Best PS3 game(uncharted 3,killzone3)
Best Wii game(Skyward Sword,Kirby,Xenoblade)
Best DS game(Kirby mass attack,prof layton,Pokemon B/W)

Best Multiplatform Game(Skyrim,Batman,rayman,BF3,Sonic Generations,Portal2)

Game of the Year(Skyward Sword,Skyrim,Batman,Rayman,Mario Kart 7, SML3D,Kirby,uncharted,Xenoblade,OOT3D,Gears of War,portal 2)

Flat-out Worst game (Duke Nukem Forever, NCIS)
Best moment in a game (Portal 2 ending, Groose Sky diving)
Best Hero in a game (Link (Skyward Sword), Ezio (Assassin's Creed: Revelations))
Best Villain in a game (Killbane (Saints Row the Third), Evil caped Bald Guy (Assassin's Creed: Revelations))
Best Storyline (Skyward Sword, Assassin's Creed: Revelations)
Best Graphics (Uncharted 3, Killzone 3)
Best "Lulz" moment in a game (any moment from Saints Row The Third or Portal 2)
Best Trailer (Saints Row: The Third, Assassin's Creed Revelations)

zmanrwks wrote:

Smash wrote:Best Soundtrack (Mother,Touhou)

This is 2011 GotY. Mother is not allowed.

@Linko: Tthis is NOT ACTUAL voting/nominations. I just want games to support your idea, they won't exactly count towards anything other than proof.

I know its not nominations, but the person who said best meme creating game left out Skyrim.

This forum used to be TheBrawlingYoshi's...then it took an arrow to the knee

Zeeman, do you want to do GotY for this year? I know you'd do a better job than I can.