[edited version of the previous icon voting thread]

To create a contest that's perfectly fair, please:

A) Don't vote for yourself
B) Don't make duplicate accounts to vote for yourself
C) Give us a reason why you voted.

If your vote doesn't have an opinion, it will not be counted. To make sure all is fair we ask you to judge based on the colors, the render, the positioning of the characters (not the characters themselves such as "LUIGI ISN'T THERE, IT SUCKS"), the contrast, and everything else that makes an icon, an icon.

The winner gets to modify his icons, aka to fix the errors the others have requested/noticed.

The current icon set is not contesting this time, as it sucks, by being default.

Refrain from harsh criticism such as "it sucks dick, add more color contrast" because not everybody is as "good" as you. If you have criticism, SAY it, don't leave it open-ended.


Vote for a 1st and 2nd place.
1st place will gain 3 points
2nd place will gain 1 point


Contestants:

Pikmintendo's icon set: https://i.imgur.com/tVVHK.png
Zmanrwks' icon set: https://i.imgur.com/Y6cfb.png
SRB1996's icon set: https://i.imgur.com/saQTG.png
SRB1996's DS icon set: https://i.imgur.com/BFyYY.png
Skochko's icon set: https://i.imgur.com/WTkEq.png

Current standings:
0. Joe - 9001 points
1. Skochko - 18 points
2. SRB1996 - 10 points
3. Zmanrwks - 5 point
4. Pikmintendo - 2 point
5. SRB1996 [DS set] - 1 points

Excuse my double post, like always.
I give 3 points to Sean for his colorful balloons that fit the forum so well. I didn't see that coming. 1 point is for Zman and his epic sexyness. Especially, Bomb Omb. Too good.

SRB1996 gets 3 points, and Scotch gets 1. I really like the balloons because they're not too generic, and they just look really nice, therefore I gave the guy 3 points. I picked scotch for the 1 point cuz triforce.

Skochko, I will give you 3 points. I Like yours because they follow the Nintendo theme and they are quite simple, they stick out to me. Pikmentendo gets a point for following the Nintendo theme and following a the New posts, locked, no new posts theme, but the didn't stick out to me.

ok I vote for sean first skoch second, lets take a look at them all.

pikmentendo: uhh wtf? eyes and baby sucking on something and yoshi? these icons are supposed to represent locked no new posts and new posts yes? these make no sense sorry(but the eye is good cause its like view only so I approve)

zman: again like pikmentendo what is the point of these they dont explain anything by looking at them for first time like a new comer.

sean: they are nice and nice I like. (the ds big suck tho)

skochko: they look pretty but dont explain so meh atleast better then ugly and dont explain :PPP

so rly this isnt contest on which is best its one of which dont suck :PP

3 points to sean, i really liked his and it went well with the current theme.
1 point to mama cus like everybody else, it did have nintendo characters, but they weren't random and fitted fair with the theme.
-3 points to joe, fucking joe

Updated the scoreboard. Dooba, you are irrelevant. Shut up

3 points to Skoch, because they fit the theme. 1 point to zman, because they also fit the theme better that i thought.

Pik: They would've been better with the old theme, but not so much with this one.

Zman: I like these the best, but cannot vote for him.

Sean's set one: I don't like it. Rather uninteresting.

Sean's set two (DS): I like this one better, a bit.

Skoch: Pretty decent.

I'll give 3 to Skoch, 1 to Sean's DS set.

"Pretty decent" wins 3 points? Wow Zman, it must be hard to please you... xD

Skochko wrote:"Pretty decent" wins 3 points? Wow Zman, it must be hard to please you... xD

I'll be honest, this batch of icons weren't the best.

I vote for Mama because of Sexy and centered icons.

Smash560 wrote:I vote for Mama because of Sexy and centered icons.

What do you mean by "centered icons"? You also need to give 1 point more to someone.

I give 1 point to Pik's, also what I mean is kinda hard to explain

skoch's gets 3, and sean's gets 1

roshipower wrote:skoch's gets 3, and sean's gets 1

Dude, you have to tell us WHY should we get points. What did you like? I will not count in your vote until you give us a reason.

I give 3 Points to Pikmintendo because I think his pictures match [Locked, New Posts, and No New Posts] Well.

I also give 1 point to skoch because I just think his look really nice xD

FFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFF
This is a bloody tough one.

Skochko - 3 points
It matches perfectly with the forum, and the icons in a sense go together as well
SBR quote bubbles - 1 point
again, it matches with the forum and have a general theme that keep them intact together as well.

Zman, you're were good, except they were....well not coherent with each other. I am a true believer in that icons should be similar in style and design and what not. bomb omb and metaknight were nice, but what killed it was that dino thingy...thing

Pik, i also have the same to say to you. I love the locked icon idea as usual, but the yoshi isnt that great, but the sparky lightbulb thing whatever its name is also goes with well with the forum, since its like LIGHTING the atmosphere around it. hahahahaha


Yeah, these are my reviews after doing some calc hw. woo

I just love your opinions in graphic contests. When you approve of my icons, I feel seckshual.
And Roshi, I forgot about this rule (which is weird, as I made it), which says you have to read the first post and follow it's rules before posting. You haven't, so I'm giving you an official warning.

The contest is over. Roshi's vote can only extend the lead. I have placed the icons on the forum. I hope you like them!